This is the polling as it stands out of a few thousand reddit users who told this guy what they voted for. Glad to see Bayonetta and Geno are so high up on the list.
Characters from this list that I think are dumb and come from dumb people:
Also super happy that paper mary-o is so high.
On another note things from the list that might be cool that I hadn't considered include Monster Hunter/Palico and a fourth mii fighter (mii wizard or mii engineer or something else rad).
And finally I know I said no assist trophies but I kind of want Waluigi because gosh darnit I love comic relief characters.