digibutter.nerr Forum Index
Hey [you]! If you haven't noticed, this is now the old digibutter forums. Go over to the new site!
digibutter.nerr
It's Hi-Technicaaal!

Games that could have been great.
Goto page 1, 2  Next  
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    digibutter.nerr Forum Index -> Gaming
Author Message
Cid
Lord Krump



Joined: 21 Apr 2007
Posts: 7880

HP: 60 MP: 2 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:17 pm   Reply with quote

Looking at the history of the game industry, you see plenty of titles that appeared to have had great potential at a point in time, but ended up lackluster, disappointing or bad. What games do you believe had a great concept, but turned out poorly, in the end?

Here's a couple of my picks.



The game's concept was great. Its gameplay was to revolve around manipulating the flow of time, a relatively original and swell idea, for its time. Also, the concept of a time-traveling cat saving a princess from the clutches of evil pigs and restoring order to the universe sounds like a wonderfully quirky scenario.

However, the game itself turned out to be very disappointing. It wasn't a bad game, but it definitely wasn't anything other than "decent." This is due to, in my opinion, the frustrating controls and overall difficulty of the game. It was a hard game; every time you were hit, you died, and time was rewinded to an earlier point- sometimes, the earlier point put you in a situation where you were likely to die again.

There was a sequel, but I don't know enough about it to comment on it.

Now, that's one example of a great concept yet flawed game. Here's another.



A quirky, unusual, and original style is always a wonderful thing, in my opinion. This game had that. A unique concept that could open up a world of possibilities is also a wonderful thing. This game had that, as well. However, lazy camera control and repetitive game progression are things that games should always avoid. Sadly, this game had those.

Again, for its time, the concept was original. The game revolved around the ability to stretch just about anything you came across- this could open up a huge amount of entertainment and variety. However, the concept was wasted on the game, due to lousy controls and the fact that the game consisted of nothing but boss fights. Challenging boss fights are a good thing; however, they're not when they're the only thing in the game, besides loads of time wasted on the boring concept of repeatedly killing the same enemies over and over again to unlock "points" to fight them. Now, the developer is known for tough boss fights, but this is overkill.

It's a shame that a wonderful concept ended out creating a poor game. This one was forgotten by time, and I'd be surprised to see if anyone remembers this game.

Anyway, those are two games that I feel could have been great, but ended up being poor. What about the rest of you?
Back to top
The Highwind Goods Store    
Simsmagic
Aggrieved
Vampire


Joined: 13 Jun 2007
Posts: 10482

HP: 28 MP: 1 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:25 pm   Reply with quote

Sonic '06. 'Nuff said.
Back to top
Gorgeon's Weapons Shop    
Hellza Ballza
Goron Mask
Dead
Dead


Joined: 14 Jul 2007
Posts: 29930

HP: 0 MP: 5 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:29 pm   Reply with quote

Shadow the hedgehog.
Back to top
Some store that sells shit    
Jet
Super Gwag Meister
Vampire


Joined: 20 Oct 2007
Posts: 1690

HP: 80 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:32 pm   Reply with quote

Goron Mask wrote:
Shadow the hedgehog.
Horrible game. Is it the first nintendo game that violent?
Back to top
Mario Kart Central    
Magmma
Gengar
Burning Vampire


Joined: 27 Aug 2007
Posts: 2073

HP: 1 MP: 1 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:39 pm   Reply with quote

Jet wrote:
Goron Mask wrote:
Shadow the hedgehog.
Horrible game. Is it the first nintendo game that violent?

Uh, Sega?
mirite?
Back to top
Lawl Shop    
Ocelot
Twytch



Joined: 12 Oct 2007
Posts: 14225

HP: 100 MP: 1 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:40 pm   Reply with quote

Oh, I'm going APE SHIT on this thread.



The original Knights of the Old Republic was great - it was a well balanced RPG with an awesome storyline that had an extremely expansive backstory. The first sucked you in, and made you care about your partners and how your choices, Light or Dark, affected them. There were a ton of plot twists, involving memory loss and betrayal.

The second game, if anything good can be said about it, improved upon the game mechanic allowing you to gain "Influence" on certain Party members and loose it the same way. It featured a love triangle for both Male and Female characters. The Handmaiden and Vistas, a trainee from your old mentor before you were exiled, and a dark jedi sent to assassinate you for the males. For the females, you had your choice between Atton and the Disciple - Atton was the Han Solo-ish pilot you find locked up in the starting area with a dark past, and the Disciple is a historian studying the Jedi ruins on Dantoonie, although he's familiar with you from before in more ways than one. They added new Feats, Powers, and new Sub classes like Jedi Watchman, Sith Maurader, etc.

The BAD part was, however, that is was rushed like hell. I'm not kidding, the game is literally half finished. They cut 2 Planets, and a storyline critical area that was mentioned numerous times and dropped like nothing ever happened. There were MULTIPLE endings, about 7 of them, but they narrowed it down to 2 that had no impact whatsoever on the game's storyline itself. The end game seems horribly put together, and what could - no, WOULD have been a terrific game was limited by the money-hungry hands of LucasARTs.

I think the reason the second sucked so much was because the franchise was bought by Obsidian from Bioware, and the game had none of the charm it had the first time around... There MIGHT BE a Third One, still made by Obsidian but not rushed like hell, and there are rumors of an MMORPG made by Bioware, the original creators, set sometime during the first game. I just hope they don't *crag* it up again... >_>
Back to top
Outer Heaven    
TooManyToasters
Paper_Waluigi



Joined: 20 May 2007
Posts: 10343

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 1



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 5:49 pm   Reply with quote

Jet wrote:
Goron Mask wrote:
Shadow the hedgehog.
Horrible game. Is it the first nintendo game that violent?

.___________________.
Uh... no. No it's not.
Also, Sonic and the Secret Rings. I thought it would be Sonic's return to glory, but the controls were horrible, and the gameplay was way too shallow.
Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones. It was good, but it was too easy and the story sucked balls.
Back to top
asdf    
See?
Popple



Joined: 30 Apr 2007
Posts: 14001

HP: 99 MP: 8 Lives: 10



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 6:23 pm   Reply with quote

Pokemon D/P.

Because it's the exact same crap and people still bought it.
Back to top
Popple's Secret Hideout    
Poyo!
Kirby



Joined: 21 Jun 2007
Posts: 1922

HP: 99 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 6:42 pm   Reply with quote

Rayman Raving Rabbid Series
The first one was going to be what looked like a great new platformer/beat-em-up that returned to the traditional Rayman style (including gibberish with subtitles), but it was turned into a minigame colection which was fun but lacked variety and had quite a few duds.

The second one looked like a huge improvement over the original (still minigames though) but ultimately failed in every way possible.
-bad, blocky graphics
-unresponsive controls
-almost no 1-player fun whatsoever
-all the good parts of the first game were made terrible
-all the bad parts were made worse
-minigames lack variety (even more so that the first game)
-no story or motivation to complete
-no definite end to the game
-Rayman somehow lost 90% of his brain cells and now acts and sounds like a rabbid, and he looks like some sort of hack
-the same jokes are recycled from the first one
-Nunchuk is required but is rarely used

...whew
Back to top
Kirby-Mart    
Nastasia



Joined: 13 May 2007
Posts: 8479

HP: 100 MP: 0 Lives: 1



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 7:20 pm   Reply with quote

Popple wrote:
Pokemon D/P.

Because it's the exact same crap and people still bought it.


Agreed. I bought that game thinking it would be something new and awesome, especially since it supposedly had a bunch of new features and stuff...but now that I've beaten the Pokemon League, the only thing I use that game for is battling people on WiFi. Other than that, there's nothing really to do, except for a few lame and boring things, like completing the Pokedex, entering contests, and a few other stupid little things....I was really expecting this game to be like G/S/C, but it was 10 times worse than it. Seriously. Only thing that's better about D/P is the graphics, compared to G/S/C....but who cares about graphics? As long as the graphics aren't that horrible, I'm fine with it. It's the game that matters to me.
Back to top
Nastasia's Shop    
oar
Super Maiq the Liar



Joined: 23 May 2007
Posts: 17919

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 7:50 pm   Reply with quote

Nastasia wrote:
Popple wrote:
Pokemon D/P.

Because it's the exact same crap and people still bought it.


Agreed. I bought that game thinking it would be something new and awesome, especially since it supposedly had a bunch of new features and stuff...but now that I've beaten the Pokemon League, the only thing I use that game for is battling people on WiFi. Other than that, there's nothing really to do, except for a few lame and boring things, like completing the Pokedex, entering contests, and a few other stupid little things....I was really expecting this game to be like G/S/C, but it was 10 times worse than it. Seriously. Only thing that's better about D/P is the graphics, compared to G/S/C....but who cares about graphics? As long as the graphics aren't that horrible, I'm fine with it. It's the game that matters to me.


Well, you get to play tag with anyone who is within a 10 ft radius of you...

...yeah.

Now for M'aiq's kinda list:

The Burger King games:

Great idea. Too glitchy. Bad graphics. Repetive jarble sounds.

Dead or Alive 4:

The f***ing difficulty, along with a boss named "Alpha 152" keeps M'aiq from saying he liked this game lots.

Sonic 360/PS3:

Looked awesome, had a good demo, but the game just outright sucked.
Back to top
Tamriellic Titles    
Boomer (redundancy!)
Boomer
Vampire


Joined: 18 Apr 2007
Posts: 810

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 10:38 pm   Reply with quote



Wow. Ok, this game had crazy potential...but failed horribly, SSSSS-BLAM. It's been dubbed Disney's version of Pokemon, and it does have a sort of "catch em all" feel, but this was kinda ruined by the fact that there are only a few dozen spectrobes.

Baby spectrobes are used to search for fossils (to get more spectrobes), minerals (to level up your spectrobes without battling), and cubes (most of which are useless). adult spectrobes (and they can also "evolve" to a better form) can battle. each one has anywhere from 1 to around 6 special actions. battles are in real time, but the addition of a meter to restrict when you can attack is...bad. In a battle, you control Rallen, a horribly weak human, and two spectrobes. you ALWAYS fight three enemies at a time.

your two spectrobes can unleash team attacks in battle, which does slight damage to all enemies. if your spectrobes are friends (this is accomplished in an incubator), their team attacks do a negligible amount more.

The storyline is where this game fails the most. its only a few hours long, and basically revolves around getting 3 special rocks, which enable you to get to the final battle (which is extremely easy, by the way).
There are three types of spectrobes. at a certain point in the game, you have to go into an area where two of the types are constantly hurt. If you haven't trained any spectrobes of the third type, you're pretty much dead.

the wi-fi could have been great, but of course they don't let you battle or trade...all you can do is download some crap that you probably already have, SSSSS-BOOM.

the addition of several "black holes" after you beat the final boss is the game's attempt at replay value. a black hole consists of as many as 60 battles in a row without healing...and gets old really fast.

I played Spectrobes for about a week. after I got every species of spectrobe, I stopped caring. This game just could have been so much better...
Back to top
Boomer's Explosive Shop    
OH GOD
Manpersonguything
Werewolf


Joined: 30 Jul 2007
Posts: 7249

HP: 100 MP: 8 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:34 pm   Reply with quote

Boomer wrote:


Wow. Ok, this game had crazy potential...but failed horribly, SSSSS-BLAM. It's been dubbed Disney's version of Pokemon, and it does have a sort of "catch em all" feel, but this was kinda ruined by the fact that there are only a few dozen spectrobes.

Baby spectrobes are used to search for fossils (to get more spectrobes), minerals (to level up your spectrobes without battling), and cubes (most of which are useless). adult spectrobes (and they can also "evolve" to a better form) can battle. each one has anywhere from 1 to around 6 special actions. battles are in real time, but the addition of a meter to restrict when you can attack is...bad. In a battle, you control Rallen, a horribly weak human, and two spectrobes. you ALWAYS fight three enemies at a time.

your two spectrobes can unleash team attacks in battle, which does slight damage to all enemies. if your spectrobes are friends (this is accomplished in an incubator), their team attacks do a negligible amount more.

The storyline is where this game fails the most. its only a few hours long, and basically revolves around getting 3 special rocks, which enable you to get to the final battle (which is extremely easy, by the way).
There are three types of spectrobes. at a certain point in the game, you have to go into an area where two of the types are constantly hurt. If you haven't trained any spectrobes of the third type, you're pretty much dead.

the wi-fi could have been great, but of course they don't let you battle or trade...all you can do is download some crap that you probably already have, SSSSS-BOOM.

the addition of several "black holes" after you beat the final boss is the game's attempt at replay value. a black hole consists of as many as 60 battles in a row without healing...and gets old really fast.

I played Spectrobes for about a week. after I got every species of spectrobe, I stopped caring. This game just could have been so much better...

When I saw that game, I smelt over advertized pokemon Rip-off.
Back to top
TWEWY Pins    
Yoshi
Vampire


Joined: 15 Dec 2007
Posts: 12475

HP: 60 MP: 6 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 9:50 am   Reply with quote

GAlaxy. *puts up flame shield* Sixteen hours of gameplay. fifty if you want to beat it 100%
Back to top
PSI and more    
Sind
Vampire


Joined: 01 Oct 2007
Posts: 1702
HP: 90 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Wed Feb 06, 2008 11:57 am   Reply with quote

Sonic and the secret rings.

It was a good game, but it could have been alot better.
Back to top
   
Display posts from previous:   
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    digibutter.nerr Forum Index -> Gaming
All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group