digibutter.nerr Forum Index
Hey [you]! If you haven't noticed, this is now the old digibutter forums. Go over to the new site!
digibutter.nerr
It's Hi-Technicaaal!

Gender Roles
Goto page 1, 2  Next  
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    digibutter.nerr Forum Index -> General Discussion
Author Message
Cid
Lord Krump



Joined: 21 Apr 2007
Posts: 7880

HP: 60 MP: 2 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 9:17 pm   Reply with quote

No flaming in this topic. Keep it reasonable, and intelligent- I'll be watching it, and if you resort to name-calling or flaming based upon differing viewpoints, you will be striked. Let me steal a post I made on another site to help explain my opinion, and get the discussion started:

Quote:
I believe that the importance of gender roles are declining; in other words, gender roles are losing their "importance" or "strength." After all, gender roles have been on a steady decline throughout history- more women have left behind the traditional "house" roles of marriage, and both males and females are gradually being found in career positions that, historically, they haven't been found in.

That's what we know. Now, let's get in to future predictions and theories and crap. Let's take this a step further- Let's say that, in the future, we will advance to the point where gender roles, and gender identity, will be virtually nonexistant. Sexism will cease, as both males and females will be seen as equals, except for sexual organs and functions.

Now, let's take this another step further- what if we come to the point where science will alter the human race, and we become, physically, sexless? This would go hand-in-hand with the possibility of reaching immortality through medical and scientific advancement.

Or, in the other route, gender roles and gender identity will always have a certain amount of importance in determining who someone is; moreso than education, skill, or creativity.

Well, there's three possibilities for the future of gender roles; and there are probably many, many more out there. So, discuss. Are gender roles on the decline? Do you have a more extreme view, and believe they will become virtually nonexistant? Or do you believe they will always have some level of prominence? Let's discuss.


Essentially, I believe that gender roles/identity are slowly being abandoned as time wears on (Which is a good thing, because they are, in a way, sexist. "Gender identity" reinforces stereotypes associated with genders and the way genders should behave, which I firmly disagree with; if a man, say, likes certain so-called feminine things, it is sexist to call him more "womanly" or less of a man. Likewise, if a man is completely macho, it is sexist to call him "more manly." Gender identities and gender roles reaffirm this sexism, and I see it best for society to abandon them. "Gender identity" and "gender role" were created by society long ago to put human beings in a definite place, limiting their freedom, as I see it. One is who one is, and one's sex shouldn't determine who one is, as I see it. One shouldn't be classified.); eventually, they will be nonexistant, I believe, and genders/sex won't be determining factors about who someone is, and the stereotypes associated with them will cease. That's what I believe, now explain what you believe. Let's discuss.


Last edited by Lord Krump on Mon Jun 02, 2008 7:26 am; edited 8 times in total
Back to top
The Highwind Goods Store    
Noble Swordsman
Meta Knight



Joined: 02 Jun 2007
Posts: 1493

HP: 100 MP: 4 Lives: 1



PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 9:51 pm   Reply with quote

I believe a person's gender should be chosen by that person alone. It is their choice to be what they consider themselves to be on the inside, no matter what the outside appearance of the person is. It is madness that people have reached the point of becoming obscenely insulting to those that are unsure or those that disagree with what gender they had been born with. It is outragious.

It is even more outragious that parents are now trying to control what gender their child grows up to be. As I said before, it is only the persons choice of what they want to be, not others.

Now then. Gender roles have been around for centuries. I myself believe that this will not change. There are certain theories of how such an occurance is. One is the passionate theory, where the person decides upon themself to be what they want to be. The other is the genetic theory, that certain persons are induced via genes that cause a mental instability, thus causing the gender role. It can be stated that such an occurance is numerically outnumbered by the amount of persons that choose to be the female or male gender role in what I called the passionate theory.

Unfortunately, the act of being transexual or transgendered is frowned upon and considered uncivil. Many, because of the corruption of such religious branches (I will not state which ones, for fear of an uprising against me. I am,m however, Agnostic) that such an act is considered mutilation, even sin against the god that they believe in. They fear playing against god. They fear the uniqueness of the person who is, what they refer to as gender challenged, and do not wish to have a possible enemy against them. Of course, this is only my opinion on what I have seen and researched over the years.
Back to top
The Halberd's Hold    
ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWA
Francine



Joined: 30 May 2007
Posts: 8580

HP: 78 MP: 4 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 9:54 pm   Reply with quote

The human mind will always make aspects superior to another.
Back to top
The Shop on a Hill    
Super ShadowArticuno



Joined: 10 Jun 2007
Posts: 29080

HP: 99 MP: 5 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Sun Jun 01, 2008 11:01 pm   Reply with quote

Exactly what Francine said.

As humans, most of us aren't gifted with the intelligence to see true equality, and as soon as gender roles are competely forgotten, they will resurface, either as the same as in the past or flipped inside out and hung upside-down.

In other words, female supremacy is inevitable, and the term house husband will be used a lot more often.
Back to top
A Bucket of Stuff    
CFH
Ligador



Joined: 20 Jan 2008
Posts: 5136

HP: 100 MP: 6 Lives: 2



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 9:14 am   Reply with quote

Hm. Personally, I believe sexism comes from our roots. We were animals just like the others in before. Look at the lions: Are there gender roles, and "manly" and "womanly" things? Yes, I could say. Female lions are responsible for hunting, male lions are responsible for protecting the family. Having many fur is "manly", having little fur is "womanly". Heck, I've even seen that the female lions must submit to a male, and if her male dies, she has to seek another one. Usually, she's forced to stay with her ex-husband's killer.

And even deeper on our roots, why does genders exist in first place? Take a look at how sex was created. Waaaay in before, there were many many unicelular beings inhabiting the water. They would seek perfection by hitting each other, thus exchanging genes, which offered improvemnts. There were two sorts of beings that would have the most gene interactions: The little agile ones, and the enormous bold ones. Later, as pluricelular beings started to come to be, some became males with a lot of tiny sexual cells, and some became females with a few larger sexual cells.

So, technically, males and females were only made to differ in one way: The males were made to have the tiny agile spermatozoids, the females were made to have the huge bold ovules. Nothing else.

But later, male and female grew huger gaping differences, which even went to affect the way the brain functions -- hence, men tend to be pratical, women tend to be emotional.

I think that the genders need to be both equalized and separated. Man and woman should be treated as equals, but as they have such different organisms, there needs to be, for example, medicine for women. The society nowadays is based on the previous one, which focused on men's needs, so we need to adapt the society to women's needs, specially when it comes to their bodies -- on the inside, of course.

The problem is that our marketing business is a true bummer, and one that loves to crumble all of our achievments. Children at early ages learn to be sexist because the media pushes them towards it. If you are a male kid and you have a girl friend, your friends will either call you gay, or will joke around saying you have a love affair.

And to add up to it, Francine and ShadowArticuno said it already. Human race seeks for the old "i r bettar dan u lol". That way, it was enforced that they use genders as a sorry excuse to think they're better. Both maleists, who usually are old-fashioned and think women belong in the kitchen, and feminists, who usually aren't all that mature and are all like "lol bois suk". These two, then again, are mere stereotypes, and whatever is the reason you have to be sexist for your own gender, it ends up in boasting.
_________________
My siggy is original.
Back to top
   
Mister I
Almaz



Joined: 22 Apr 2007
Posts: 19527

HP: 43 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 9:42 am   Reply with quote

The human race is based completely on self-preservation. Therefore, we can assume that early in history, the gender more suited for the barbaric needs of what would be considered "prehistory" established itself as superior. This would be the male gender. Now, I can safely say that very few have evolved mentally through prehistoric times, as these roles are rarely, if not ever, altered. And why? Because the human race, in the act of self-preservation, is afraid of change.

Will there be a day that all sexes can be equal? When all can truly be who they are on the inside? When life can move on from dealing with such an issue and move on to what's really important (NOT war either)? I cannot say...clouded by the dark side, the future is. I can only hope for a better, less blank-ist tomorrow.
Back to top
Temple of I    
ERECTIN' A DICK
Miku Hatsune
Vampire


Joined: 05 Jun 2007
Posts: 13497

HP: 5 MP: 4 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 9:48 am   Reply with quote

Meta Knight wrote:
I believe a person's gender should be chosen by that person alone. It is their choice to be what they consider themselves to be on the inside, no matter what the outside appearance of the person is. It is madness that people have reached the point of becoming obscenely insulting to those that are unsure or those that disagree with what gender they had been born with. It is outragious.

It is even more outragious that parents are now trying to control what gender their child grows up to be. As I said before, it is only the persons choice of what they want to be, not others.

Now then. Gender roles have been around for centuries. I myself believe that this will not change. There are certain theories of how such an occurance is. One is the passionate theory, where the person decides upon themself to be what they want to be. The other is the genetic theory, that certain persons are induced via genes that cause a mental instability, thus causing the gender role. It can be stated that such an occurance is numerically outnumbered by the amount of persons that choose to be the female or male gender role in what I called the passionate theory.

Unfortunately, the act of being transexual or transgendered is frowned upon and considered uncivil. Many, because of the corruption of such religious branches (I will not state which ones, for fear of an uprising against me. I am,m however, Agnostic) that such an act is considered mutilation, even sin against the god that they believe in. They fear playing against god. They fear the uniqueness of the person who is, what they refer to as gender challenged, and do not wish to have a possible enemy against them. Of course, this is only my opinion on what I have seen and researched over the years.
Basiclly what I was going to say in a nut shell.

I mean, if you want to be a guy, be a guy and same for the other gender.
Back to top
Anime and Image Shop    
oar
Super Maiq the Liar



Joined: 23 May 2007
Posts: 17919

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 9:59 am   Reply with quote

Petey Piranha wrote:
Meta Knight wrote:
I believe a person's gender should be chosen by that person alone. It is their choice to be what they consider themselves to be on the inside, no matter what the outside appearance of the person is. It is madness that people have reached the point of becoming obscenely insulting to those that are unsure or those that disagree with what gender they had been born with. It is outragious.

It is even more outragious that parents are now trying to control what gender their child grows up to be. As I said before, it is only the persons choice of what they want to be, not others.

Now then. Gender roles have been around for centuries. I myself believe that this will not change. There are certain theories of how such an occurance is. One is the passionate theory, where the person decides upon themself to be what they want to be. The other is the genetic theory, that certain persons are induced via genes that cause a mental instability, thus causing the gender role. It can be stated that such an occurance is numerically outnumbered by the amount of persons that choose to be the female or male gender role in what I called the passionate theory.

Unfortunately, the act of being transexual or transgendered is frowned upon and considered uncivil. Many, because of the corruption of such religious branches (I will not state which ones, for fear of an uprising against me. I am,m however, Agnostic) that such an act is considered mutilation, even sin against the god that they believe in. They fear playing against god. They fear the uniqueness of the person who is, what they refer to as gender challenged, and do not wish to have a possible enemy against them. Of course, this is only my opinion on what I have seen and researched over the years.
Basiclly what I was going to say in a nut shell.

I mean, if you want to be a guy, be a guy and same for the other gender.


The entire subject of changing genders is just disgusting. M'aiq believes that you should not be allowed to change every single aspect of your life, some things should remain permanant, such as hair/skin/eye color, gender, (insert-word-involving-plastic-surgery-here). M'aiq does understand surgery in general, but something about those is just wrong.

And to be perfectly honest, how would you like it if you woke up one morning and your wife told you she was a man once? Spooky...
Back to top
Tamriellic Titles    
ERECTIN' A DICK
Miku Hatsune
Vampire


Joined: 05 Jun 2007
Posts: 13497

HP: 5 MP: 4 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 10:01 am   Reply with quote

Maiq the Liar wrote:
Petey Piranha wrote:
Meta Knight wrote:
I believe a person's gender should be chosen by that person alone. It is their choice to be what they consider themselves to be on the inside, no matter what the outside appearance of the person is. It is madness that people have reached the point of becoming obscenely insulting to those that are unsure or those that disagree with what gender they had been born with. It is outragious.

It is even more outragious that parents are now trying to control what gender their child grows up to be. As I said before, it is only the persons choice of what they want to be, not others.

Now then. Gender roles have been around for centuries. I myself believe that this will not change. There are certain theories of how such an occurance is. One is the passionate theory, where the person decides upon themself to be what they want to be. The other is the genetic theory, that certain persons are induced via genes that cause a mental instability, thus causing the gender role. It can be stated that such an occurance is numerically outnumbered by the amount of persons that choose to be the female or male gender role in what I called the passionate theory.

Unfortunately, the act of being transexual or transgendered is frowned upon and considered uncivil. Many, because of the corruption of such religious branches (I will not state which ones, for fear of an uprising against me. I am,m however, Agnostic) that such an act is considered mutilation, even sin against the god that they believe in. They fear playing against god. They fear the uniqueness of the person who is, what they refer to as gender challenged, and do not wish to have a possible enemy against them. Of course, this is only my opinion on what I have seen and researched over the years.
Basiclly what I was going to say in a nut shell.

I mean, if you want to be a guy, be a guy and same for the other gender.


The entire subject of changing genders is just disgusting. M'aiq believes that you should not be allowed to change every single aspect of your life, some things should remain permanant, such as hair/skin/eye color, gender, (insert-word-involving-plastic-surgery-here). M'aiq does understand surgery in general, but something about those is just wrong.

And to be perfectly honest, how would you like it if you woke up one morning and your wife told you she was a man once? Spooky...
Why? Its your body. YOu should be able to do whatever you want with it.
Back to top
Anime and Image Shop    
Master of Puppets...
The Chaos Heart



Joined: 17 Jul 2007
Posts: 4568

HP: 100 MP: 6 Lives: 22



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 10:03 am   Reply with quote

No. Don't get me started again.

I'm going to say this and hopefully not come back with another wall of text.

You sick minded basterds. You disgusting pigs. Those of you who classify people based off of their sex, YOU are the unitelligent. You ignorant fools, no person is greater than another because of gender. As humans, you have the ability to be just as good as any man or woman in anything (except in terms of the way your bodies work) you do. The ONLY thing that should classify people is the limits of their abilities. Gender roles are insolent laws created by incompetent assholes.


Last edited by The Chaos Heart on Mon Jun 02, 2008 11:28 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Dimension C    
oar
Super Maiq the Liar



Joined: 23 May 2007
Posts: 17919

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 10:57 am   Reply with quote

Petey Piranha wrote:
Maiq the Liar wrote:
Petey Piranha wrote:
Meta Knight wrote:
I believe a person's gender should be chosen by that person alone. It is their choice to be what they consider themselves to be on the inside, no matter what the outside appearance of the person is. It is madness that people have reached the point of becoming obscenely insulting to those that are unsure or those that disagree with what gender they had been born with. It is outragious.

It is even more outragious that parents are now trying to control what gender their child grows up to be. As I said before, it is only the persons choice of what they want to be, not others.

Now then. Gender roles have been around for centuries. I myself believe that this will not change. There are certain theories of how such an occurance is. One is the passionate theory, where the person decides upon themself to be what they want to be. The other is the genetic theory, that certain persons are induced via genes that cause a mental instability, thus causing the gender role. It can be stated that such an occurance is numerically outnumbered by the amount of persons that choose to be the female or male gender role in what I called the passionate theory.

Unfortunately, the act of being transexual or transgendered is frowned upon and considered uncivil. Many, because of the corruption of such religious branches (I will not state which ones, for fear of an uprising against me. I am,m however, Agnostic) that such an act is considered mutilation, even sin against the god that they believe in. They fear playing against god. They fear the uniqueness of the person who is, what they refer to as gender challenged, and do not wish to have a possible enemy against them. Of course, this is only my opinion on what I have seen and researched over the years.
Basiclly what I was going to say in a nut shell.

I mean, if you want to be a guy, be a guy and same for the other gender.


The entire subject of changing genders is just disgusting. M'aiq believes that you should not be allowed to change every single aspect of your life, some things should remain permanant, such as hair/skin/eye color, gender, (insert-word-involving-plastic-surgery-here). M'aiq does understand surgery in general, but something about those is just wrong.

And to be perfectly honest, how would you like it if you woke up one morning and your wife told you she was a man once? Spooky...
Why? Its your body. YOu should be able to do whatever you want with it.
People who have to alter their body through unnatural means, be it things like steroids or surgery, to think they are good are downright pathetic. It's like cheating on the test of life.

But, you know, half of the people on this site are yesmen most of the time, so M'aiq won't even bother arguing about it.
Back to top
Tamriellic Titles    
Strawberry-san
Celeste Dimentia



Joined: 03 Jul 2007
Posts: 11104

HP: 100 MP: 0 Lives: 3



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 1:48 pm   Reply with quote

Maiq the Liar wrote:

The entire subject of changing genders is just disgusting. M'aiq believes that you should not be allowed to change every single aspect of your life, some things should remain permanant, such as hair/skin/eye color, gender, (insert-word-involving-plastic-surgery-here). M'aiq does understand surgery in general, but something about those is just wrong.

And to be perfectly honest, how would you like it if you woke up one morning and your wife told you she was a man once? Spooky...


You mean changing sex? Say, to make it match your gender and truly be happy? To some people it is wrong - for them. That's fine, they would be cisgendered individuals or transgendered people who find that they do not need SRS. Anyway, I'm not intending to change my sex just because I feel like it. I'm doing it to act against the depression that has hold on me, which I really cannot help. I think it's more of a beautiful thing rather than disgusting when viewed on a deeper level, say in the instance of a transgirl making her sex match to who she truly is. It's the consideration that the hand of cards dealt to you were NOT the proper ones. This challenges some beliefs, of that I am aware. But I will respect people's right to their beliefs as long as it does not harm anyone. I'm just putting in my own opinion on this.

Oh, and I personally would have to be completely honest with any person I'm starting to enter a serious relationship with, rather than catch them out of nowhere. That is not fair to them. Then they will either reject me, or accept me for who I am - perhaps a rarer case, but all the more valuable as a result, and someone truly meant for me. ^^
Back to top
Dimension D    
Poison
Super Postman
Jailed Vampire
Jailed


Joined: 18 Apr 2007
Posts: 6363

HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 11



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 2:33 pm   Reply with quote

I honestly Hate Gender roles.

There I said it, Why Because it promotes discrimination.

now myself being Trans I hear all the time "Oh if you hate gender roles so much why are you conforming to one" sorta spiel. Gender shouldn't be a limiting factor for employment, legal representation Personal preferences Ect Ect. But humanity as a whole (not individuals) Have a specific line of what is male what is female. These Roles are set Culturally, Religiously, Socially. so on so forth.

Plenty of people live with the grey area of Humanity's Line, Just to create controversy. However I and most Trans I've had contact with do not wish to live only to create controversy. Just as you would say are unfortunately part of controversy. Not committing any thoughts to Gender Roles I believe myself Female. Yes I do have some underlined(ala society) "feminine" traits and I have some underlined "masculine" ones. it makes up me. who I am. the Individual.

however it comes onto an issue of depression. Ive never felt right I'm unhappy with my body, I want to change my body. I want to be accepted as Female. yes, but I don't want to limit myself to gender roles. In other words being Female is being honest with myself.

Being male, to me at least, the male persona I took on, was a lie that conformed to gender roles. yeah I lied to get by. so I wouldn't be chastised for feeling depressed about being in the wrong body.
so In turn the classic conformity question the answer is Living as male, for me anyway Is Conforming to a gender role.

Something that I think needs to be Said for all Trans. We aren't like this by choice, and its not an easy path those who live the path face constant persecution, Hatred, Discrimination. Would you honestly submit yourself to such trials in life By Choice? Maybe its a "sin" to be Trans but isnt it a "sin" to lie to yourself and others on a daily basis to keep yourself going?
Back to top
Poison's Boutique    
The Guy
X-Neto



Joined: 30 May 2008
Posts: 108
HP: 100 MP: 10 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 2:53 pm   Reply with quote

Humanity has a funny way of working out any momentary change, be it evolution, color of skin, or ethnic grouping, and turning it into either superiority or making others feel inferior. But that's what the human race be. A group of people wanting to live their lives to new heights of happiness and not afraid to bring a knife into the guy next to them to do it.

So, being male, there is a fact that since females are doing much more in the communities, jobs, and leadership, I feel uneasy. I mean no offense to you female members, it's an instinct and it's not something I wish to part with. All and all, a race with genderless homosapians would be strange for us, while expected for future generations and will definately iron out many issues, such as same-sex marriage and glass ceilings. However, that won't stop humans from being just that, humans.

I don't consider myself better then others, in fact, I'm just as others. If given the choice between my life and another, half the time I would choose the other. Although a future with genders missing from the equation would be a strange new outlook, it's entirely possible, and may be for the better. If mankind wasn't so barberic... well... maybe we would be a few notches higher up in life. But that won't happen, I'm not willing to change, and neither is the way we all act.
Back to top
   
Cid
Lord Krump



Joined: 21 Apr 2007
Posts: 7880

HP: 60 MP: 2 Lives: 0



PostPosted: Mon Jun 02, 2008 5:03 pm   Reply with quote

Maiq the Liar wrote:

The entire subject of changing genders is just disgusting. M'aiq believes that you should not be allowed to change every single aspect of your life, some things should remain permanant, such as hair/skin/eye color, gender, (insert-word-involving-plastic-surgery-here). M'aiq does understand surgery in general, but something about those is just wrong.

And to be perfectly honest, how would you like it if you woke up one morning and your wife told you she was a man once? Spooky...


I wouldn't call it disgusting. People have the right to mess with their bodies however they see fit, and if that makes them happy, they can do whatever they want. Well, as long as they have thought through things for a long, long time, deeply... still, even though I won't tell people not to get sex changes, I still don't agree with them, for the reason below (A quote of mine from the same Gender Role topic as the first quote):

Quote:
Sex changes; this concept reminds me of a similiar topic that I have discussed before- could sexual reassignment, or "sex changes", possibly be a form of sexism, because it demonstrates the feeling that "gender roles/identities" (In other words, the traditional or historical standards and/or stereotypes that human civilization has set for the sexes, and not what individualism has set, instead) are important, major factors in determining who someone is?


I strictly believe that genders shouldn't be determining factors for who people are, as there are much, much, much more important, individual characteristics to decide who a person is, instead of "grouping" them based upon their physical or genetic structures.
Back to top
The Highwind Goods Store    
Display posts from previous:   
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    digibutter.nerr Forum Index -> General Discussion
All times are GMT - 5 Hours
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group