I dont really like it, its kind of rough on the eyes and a little messy. I dont mean that as like an asshole response, I'm just giving my honest opinion on it.
http://i.imgur.com/kKb6ddV.png
Try that, Doops.
Like I said before, I like parts of it. I'm not so fond of the grid-ness. I think if you removed the grid part, it would be a lot better. The non-noise version is better. I also just realized that I like the top of the sign better when it is white. Tan blends in too much. But besides all that shit, it is a lot prettier. :3 The window is great.
I'd have to see what it looks like in-game to give a full opinion, but I think portions of it could work - the grass, stone and brick tiles are pretty close to the SPM style and might be a good replacement for the current sprites, but for the door, signpost and blocks the tile theme is a bit obtrusive.
I think that the grid could actually turn out nicely if the boxes weren't so dark compared to the colors next to it. Like for the stone and door, try making it so the darker colors aren't that much darker than the light. Seems like it's too big of a contrast.... Except for maybe borders, like the very edges of the door or Meow-thingy.
I don't like it either, mainly because whatever it is it won't even load for me
Try that, Doops.
Like I said before, I like parts of it. I'm not so fond of the grid-ness. I think if you removed the grid part, it would be a lot better. The non-noise version is better. I also just realized that I like the top of the sign better when it is white. Tan blends in too much. But besides all that shit, it is a lot prettier. :3 The window is great.